top of page

Preserving the Value of Jury Verdicts: Safeguarding Justice in Indiana

A gavel resting on a jury book

In the realm of the civil justice system, one crucial pillar that upholds fairness and impartiality is the institution of jury trials. Across the United States, including the state of Indiana, juries play a fundamental role in rendering verdicts that reflect the collective conscience of the community. Unfortunately, misconceptions often surround the concept of jury verdicts, with some suggesting that they yield exorbitant awards. In this post, we aim to debunk this misconception by highlighting the importance of preserving jury trials and showcasing how verdicts in Indiana are not unjustly high. Let's delve into the critical reasons why jury trials should be protected as an integral part of the civil justice system.

The Power of Collective Wisdom: Juries, consisting of individuals from diverse backgrounds and experiences, provide a unique perspective in the judicial process. This diverse composition ensures that verdicts are reached based on an amalgamation of ideas and viewpoints, rather than a single person's judgment. By placing decision-making power in the hands of a group, jury trials diminish the risk of bias or partiality. Consequently, the outcomes are more likely to be fair and representative of societal norms and values.

Preserving Citizen Participation: Jury trials serve as a mechanism for active civic engagement, allowing ordinary citizens to participate directly in the administration of justice. This opportunity empowers individuals, reinforcing their sense of ownership in the legal system and promoting a broader understanding of legal processes. By embracing jury trials, we preserve an essential element of democratic governance—direct involvement of the people in upholding the principles of justice.

Checks and Balances on Power: Juries provide a critical check on the potential abuse of power by any single entity, including large corporations, institutions, or even government bodies. The ability of juries to hold powerful entities accountable ensures that justice remains accessible to all members of society, regardless of their socio-economic status or influence. By allowing juries to decide on liability and damages, we establish a fair balance between the parties involved, providing a counterbalance to any inherent power imbalances.

Misconceptions Regarding High Verdicts: While media attention often focuses on sensationalized anecdotes of high jury verdicts, the reality is far more nuanced. The majority of civil cases result in reasonable and proportionate awards or settlements. Many factors, such as the severity of harm suffered, medical expenses, loss of income, and pain and suffering, are meticulously considered before arriving at a verdict. This diligent approach ensures that awards are fair and just, taking into account the specific circumstances of each case.

Jury trials are an indispensable cornerstone of the civil justice system in Indiana, ensuring that decisions reflect the collective conscience of the community. By protecting jury trials, we preserve a system that values fairness, civic engagement, and checks on power. As we advocate for the importance of preserving jury trials, we contribute to a legal landscape that upholds the principles of justice, protects individual rights, and safeguards the overall well-being of society.

bottom of page