When you file a lawsuit, one of the first things you’ll need to decide is whether to file in federal court or state court. This decision can have a big impact on your case, from the rules that govern the proceedings to the location of the court. Knowing the difference between federal and state court can help you make an informed decision with your attorney.
Let’s break it down:
1. Jurisdiction: Federal vs. State Court
The biggest difference between federal and state courts lies in their jurisdiction—the types of cases they are allowed to hear.
Federal Courts: Federal courts have limited jurisdiction, meaning they can only hear cases authorized by the U.S. Constitution or federal law. Typically, these include:
Cases involving federal laws or regulations (like a violation of civil rights or federal employment laws).
Diversity of citizenship cases: When the plaintiff and defendant are from different states, and the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000.
Cases involving the U.S. government or certain international issues.
State Courts: State courts have general jurisdiction, meaning they can hear nearly any type of civil or criminal case. Most cases, especially those involving family law (divorce, custody), contract disputes, personal injury claims, and property issues, are filed in state courts.
Example: If you were injured in a car crash and are suing for damages, you would generally file in state court unless the crash involves parties from different states or federal laws.
2. Procedural Differences
Federal and state courts have different rules and procedures that govern how cases are handled.
Federal Court: Federal courts follow the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. These rules are consistent across the country, which can make federal court proceedings more predictable. However, the federal rules can also be more formal and stricter, requiring more rigorous adherence to deadlines and filing requirements.
State Court: Each state has its own set of rules. While many states have adopted rules similar to the federal system, the specifics can vary significantly. State court procedures are often viewed as less rigid, but this can differ based on the state or even the individual court.
3. Judges and Juries
Federal Judges: Federal judges are appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate. They serve for life, which often gives them more independence. Federal courts may also have magistrate judges who assist with preliminary matters.
State Judges: State judges can be appointed or elected, depending on the state. They may serve fixed terms and often have to campaign for re-election or reappointment. This can influence how state court judges approach certain issues, especially in high-profile cases.
Both federal and state courts can have juries, but the selection process and qualifications for jurors may differ slightly between the two.
4. Location and Convenience
Federal Court: Federal courts are fewer in number, with only one or two courts in each state. This can make federal court less convenient, particularly if you're required to travel long distances for hearings or a trial.
State Court: State courts are far more accessible, with many courthouses located in every county. This makes state court more convenient for local disputes.
5. Appeals
If you don’t agree with a ruling, the appeals process differs between federal and state courts.
Federal Court Appeals: Appeals from federal trial courts go to one of the 13 U.S. Courts of Appeals. A case may eventually be heard by the U.S. Supreme Court, but only a small fraction of cases make it that far.
State Court Appeals: Appeals from state trial courts typically go to an intermediate state court of appeals. From there, they might go to the state supreme court. Some state court cases can be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, but only if they involve a federal issue, such as a constitutional right.
6. Types of Cases
Federal Court: Handles issues like constitutional challenges, violations of federal statutes, bankruptcy, and patent law. For example, a lawsuit claiming discrimination under federal employment laws would go to federal court.
State Court: Handles most civil cases, including personal injury claims, family law matters, contract disputes, and estate cases. For example, a personal injury lawsuit following a car crash would generally be filed in state court.
Conclusion
Choosing between federal and state court is an important decision in a civil lawsuit. While federal courts handle cases involving federal law or parties from different states, state courts have broader jurisdiction and are often more convenient for local disputes. Understanding the key differences can help you and your attorney decide where to file your case to give you the best chance of success.
At Guenin Law we handle cases in courts throughout the state as well as in Federal Courts.
Comments